|
Games you regret ever playing..
Pandemonium.Kajidourden
サーバ: Pandemonium
Game: FFXI
Posts: 993
By Pandemonium.Kajidourden 2010-04-30 17:56:14
Caitsith.Linear said: Cerberus.Ferth said: In final fantasy 7 the main character goes through numerous traumatic experiences that are revealed slowly as you play through the story and if you go out of the way to find all the little snippets of flash backs and because of this he has lost his identity. The way it's broached is done, in a literarly sense, well. It is done well.
In final fantasy 8 every main character was present in a major way in everyone elses life in their formative years. it isn't alluded to in any fashion until bam suddenly irvine remembers it. then you have a confusing as hell flashback of everyone living in the same orphanage run by cid and ednea(that's her name right?)
From a literary perspective that is a cheap plot twist... it's deus ex machina... we explain this away because guardian forces make you forget things.
***. In VIII, the characters would be common soldiers without GF's. They have to give up their memories to become powerful. It makes the characters easier to relate to, honestly. It's not hard to understand.
In VII, the characters are already supernaturally powerful and give up nothing in return. Cloud and Vincent are sorta explainable, they got injected with otherworldly beings. Maybe Aerith and RED XIII too, being unique races and all. But Tifa, Yuffie, Barret, Cid and Caitsith? Not so much.
And traumatic? *** that noise, Rydia had it just as bad. Her mother was killed, THEN her hometown got burned down, and was approached by two fairly intimidating looking men. THEN she was swallowed by Leviathan. She sure as hell didn't lose her memories. Did I mention was like, sevenish when all that happens?
Your response makes 0 sense. He was addressing a writing issue, you're talking about understanding something that we already understand.
Tifa I don't really get either, but Yuffie is a ninja, duh. Barret didn't need otherworldly powers, he had a freaking gun for an arm. Cid and caitsith? They're in the boat with Tifa lol.
Rydia is totally irrelevant to the conversation, and again you've missed the point. The plot was what he was talking about, the fact that she didnt lose her memories is, again, irrelevant because it was in no way related to the plot itself. In fact I just played through iv and her part of the story is pretty lolwut? She just appears out of nowhere after being swallowed by Leviathan and really holds no important place in the story thereafter.
サーバ: Shiva
Game: FFXI
Posts: 23653
By Shiva.Flionheart 2010-04-30 17:56:14
Sylph.Oddin said: Shiva.Flionheart said: Sylph.Oddin said: FFVII is good because it was a groundbreaking game that helped push the Playstation ahead of the competition. The first RPG that moved into the 3D realm. It had an interesting albeit hole-filled plot line. It could of been better but it could of been a lot worse. The characters were memorable and interesting although it spawned the legions of dumbass Sephiroth idiots... (Seriously, you need to *** get your head checked when you're idolizing a guy who stabs a defenseless woman in the back with a giant sword and wants to destroy the world with a giant flaming rock from outer space).
The mediocrity comes from the here and now. Looking back at it now, yeah it seems like it was over-hyped but back in its hay day it was a pretty bad *** game.
So was super mario bros, I wouldn't call it the best mario game to date.
Who said anything about it being the best? You just asked why it was good. Akibakei says it is the best in so many words.
サーバ: Shiva
Game: FFXI
Posts: 343
By Shiva.Borealis 2010-04-30 17:57:33
LOUD NOISES!
サーバ: Shiva
Game: FFXI
Posts: 23653
By Shiva.Flionheart 2010-04-30 17:58:00
Cerberus.Ferth said: Caitsith.Linear said: Cerberus.Ferth said: In final fantasy 7 the main character goes through numerous traumatic experiences that are revealed slowly as you play through the story and if you go out of the way to find all the little snippets of flash backs and because of this he has lost his identity. The way it's broached is done, in a literarly sense, well. It is done well.
In final fantasy 8 every main character was present in a major way in everyone elses life in their formative years. it isn't alluded to in any fashion until bam suddenly irvine remembers it. then you have a confusing as hell flashback of everyone living in the same orphanage run by cid and ednea(that's her name right?)
From a literary perspective that is a cheap plot twist... it's deus ex machina... we explain this away because guardian forces make you forget things.
***. In VIII, the characters would be common soldiers without GF's. They have to give up their memories to become powerful. It makes the characters easier to relate to, honestly. It's not hard to understand.
In VII, the characters are already supernaturally powerful and give up nothing in return. Cloud and Vincent are sorta explainable, they got injected with otherworldly beings. Maybe Aerith and RED XIII too, being unique races and all. But Tifa, Yuffie, Barret, Cid and Caitsith? Not so much.
And traumatic? *** that noise, Rydia had it just as bad. Her mother was killed, THEN her hometown got burned down, and was approached by two fairly intimidating looking men. THEN she was swallowed by Leviathan. She sure as hell didn't lose her memories. Did I mention was like, sevenish when all that happens?
Your points are about game mechanics, and they are completely valid. All the characters in 7 are overpowered.
I didn't say cloud's experiences were the most truamatic ever. But he was too weak to be a soldier... in desperation and shame he became a lowly grunt, and then became a guinea pig for hojo. he spent years (yes, years) stuck in a tube, until he broke out with zack. zack, a powerful, herioc image, everything cloud wanted to be so he became it, repressing memories of his shame and losing his identity.
This is a well formed plot.
In final fantasy 8, halfway through the story the decide to tell you that everyone grew up together, there was no lead in, there was no justification and quite honestly they could have made the story without the plot point entirely, but they decided to cram it in and use the junction with guardian forces as a vehicle for a totally pointless sensationalist plot point.
You can still like 8 more than 7. but it is, in a literary sense, a weak story.
Most of this plot was explained through spin offs, meaning that the story was originally full of plot holes.
Pandemonium.Kajidourden
サーバ: Pandemonium
Game: FFXI
Posts: 993
By Pandemonium.Kajidourden 2010-04-30 18:01:07
Shiva.Flionheart said: Cerberus.Ferth said: Caitsith.Linear said: Cerberus.Ferth said: In final fantasy 7 the main character goes through numerous traumatic experiences that are revealed slowly as you play through the story and if you go out of the way to find all the little snippets of flash backs and because of this he has lost his identity. The way it's broached is done, in a literarly sense, well. It is done well.
In final fantasy 8 every main character was present in a major way in everyone elses life in their formative years. it isn't alluded to in any fashion until bam suddenly irvine remembers it. then you have a confusing as hell flashback of everyone living in the same orphanage run by cid and ednea(that's her name right?)
From a literary perspective that is a cheap plot twist... it's deus ex machina... we explain this away because guardian forces make you forget things.
***. In VIII, the characters would be common soldiers without GF's. They have to give up their memories to become powerful. It makes the characters easier to relate to, honestly. It's not hard to understand.
In VII, the characters are already supernaturally powerful and give up nothing in return. Cloud and Vincent are sorta explainable, they got injected with otherworldly beings. Maybe Aerith and RED XIII too, being unique races and all. But Tifa, Yuffie, Barret, Cid and Caitsith? Not so much.
And traumatic? *** that noise, Rydia had it just as bad. Her mother was killed, THEN her hometown got burned down, and was approached by two fairly intimidating looking men. THEN she was swallowed by Leviathan. She sure as hell didn't lose her memories. Did I mention was like, sevenish when all that happens?
Your points are about game mechanics, and they are completely valid. All the characters in 7 are overpowered.
I didn't say cloud's experiences were the most truamatic ever. But he was too weak to be a soldier... in desperation and shame he became a lowly grunt, and then became a guinea pig for hojo. he spent years (yes, years) stuck in a tube, until he broke out with zack. zack, a powerful, herioc image, everything cloud wanted to be so he became it, repressing memories of his shame and losing his identity.
This is a well formed plot.
In final fantasy 8, halfway through the story the decide to tell you that everyone grew up together, there was no lead in, there was no justification and quite honestly they could have made the story without the plot point entirely, but they decided to cram it in and use the junction with guardian forces as a vehicle for a totally pointless sensationalist plot point.
You can still like 8 more than 7. but it is, in a literary sense, a weak story.
Most of this plot was explained through spin offs, meaning that the story was originally full of plot holes.
Wrong. The spinoffs only took and expanded on the story. Which one of those spinoffs explained something that wast already explained in ff7? none. Playing as zach and learning about sephiroth's rise to power so to speak is pretty irrelevant to the overall plot points. Playing as vincent AFTER the fact does what...? You're making no sense.
[+]
サーバ: Shiva
Game: FFXI
Posts: 23653
By Shiva.Flionheart 2010-04-30 18:02:28
Pandemonium.Kajidourden said: Shiva.Flionheart said: Cerberus.Ferth said: Caitsith.Linear said: Cerberus.Ferth said: In final fantasy 7 the main character goes through numerous traumatic experiences that are revealed slowly as you play through the story and if you go out of the way to find all the little snippets of flash backs and because of this he has lost his identity. The way it's broached is done, in a literarly sense, well. It is done well.
In final fantasy 8 every main character was present in a major way in everyone elses life in their formative years. it isn't alluded to in any fashion until bam suddenly irvine remembers it. then you have a confusing as hell flashback of everyone living in the same orphanage run by cid and ednea(that's her name right?)
From a literary perspective that is a cheap plot twist... it's deus ex machina... we explain this away because guardian forces make you forget things.
***. In VIII, the characters would be common soldiers without GF's. They have to give up their memories to become powerful. It makes the characters easier to relate to, honestly. It's not hard to understand.
In VII, the characters are already supernaturally powerful and give up nothing in return. Cloud and Vincent are sorta explainable, they got injected with otherworldly beings. Maybe Aerith and RED XIII too, being unique races and all. But Tifa, Yuffie, Barret, Cid and Caitsith? Not so much.
And traumatic? *** that noise, Rydia had it just as bad. Her mother was killed, THEN her hometown got burned down, and was approached by two fairly intimidating looking men. THEN she was swallowed by Leviathan. She sure as hell didn't lose her memories. Did I mention was like, sevenish when all that happens?
Your points are about game mechanics, and they are completely valid. All the characters in 7 are overpowered.
I didn't say cloud's experiences were the most truamatic ever. But he was too weak to be a soldier... in desperation and shame he became a lowly grunt, and then became a guinea pig for hojo. he spent years (yes, years) stuck in a tube, until he broke out with zack. zack, a powerful, herioc image, everything cloud wanted to be so he became it, repressing memories of his shame and losing his identity.
This is a well formed plot.
In final fantasy 8, halfway through the story the decide to tell you that everyone grew up together, there was no lead in, there was no justification and quite honestly they could have made the story without the plot point entirely, but they decided to cram it in and use the junction with guardian forces as a vehicle for a totally pointless sensationalist plot point.
You can still like 8 more than 7. but it is, in a literary sense, a weak story.
Most of this plot was explained through spin offs, meaning that the story was originally full of plot holes.
Wrong. The spinoffs only took and expanded on the story. Which one of those spinoffs explained something that wast already explained in ff7? none. Playing as zach and learning about sephiroth's rise to power so to speak is pretty irrelevant to the overall plot points. Playing as vincent AFTER the fact does what...? You're making no sense.
What Hojo did was barely explained other than "You got injected with Jenova splooge herp derp"
All of that was explained through Crisis core.
Cerberus.Ferth
サーバ: Cerberus
Game: FFXI
Posts: 78
By Cerberus.Ferth 2010-04-30 18:02:31
I am not arguing that they don't explain the memory loss in 8... I am arguing that the explanation is derivative. It adds nothing to the story and it doesn't build from anything that happened prior in the story.
If they wanted to express the sacrifices made by SeeD members for the power they receive there are numerous, more poignant ways they could have done it. Tossing a huge plot hole out there and then explaining it away through memory loss from guardian forces is not strong narrative.
[+]
サーバ: Shiva
Game: FFXI
Posts: 23653
By Shiva.Flionheart 2010-04-30 18:04:24
Cerberus.Ferth said: I am not arguing that they don't explain the memory loss in 8... I am arguing that the explanation is derivative. It adds nothing to the story and it doesn't build from anything that happened prior in the story.
If they wanted to express the sacrifices made by SeeD members for the power they receive there are numerous, more poignant ways they could have done it. Tossing a huge plot hole out there and then explaining it away through memory loss from guardian forces is not strong narrative.
I disagree. I find the entire explanation as to how cloud had his power far more shallow.
Cerberus.Ferth
サーバ: Cerberus
Game: FFXI
Posts: 78
By Cerberus.Ferth 2010-04-30 18:05:42
Shiva.Flionheart said:
What Hojo did was barely explained other than "You got injected with Jenova splooge herp derp"
All of that was explained through Crisis core.
I played about halfway through crisis core... I didn't get to the point where they were imprisoned together (if it even gets that far.)
There are cutscenes you can find in 7 that show zack and cloud stuck in the basement of shinra mansion and show them after they've escaped, and how zack dies.
All of that information is available in the game itself. Hell cloud even tells you about it before you can view the cutscenes.
Pandemonium.Kajidourden
サーバ: Pandemonium
Game: FFXI
Posts: 993
By Pandemonium.Kajidourden 2010-04-30 18:06:36
Shiva.Flionheart said: Pandemonium.Kajidourden said: Shiva.Flionheart said: Cerberus.Ferth said: Caitsith.Linear said: Cerberus.Ferth said: In final fantasy 7 the main character goes through numerous traumatic experiences that are revealed slowly as you play through the story and if you go out of the way to find all the little snippets of flash backs and because of this he has lost his identity. The way it's broached is done, in a literarly sense, well. It is done well.
In final fantasy 8 every main character was present in a major way in everyone elses life in their formative years. it isn't alluded to in any fashion until bam suddenly irvine remembers it. then you have a confusing as hell flashback of everyone living in the same orphanage run by cid and ednea(that's her name right?)
From a literary perspective that is a cheap plot twist... it's deus ex machina... we explain this away because guardian forces make you forget things.
***. In VIII, the characters would be common soldiers without GF's. They have to give up their memories to become powerful. It makes the characters easier to relate to, honestly. It's not hard to understand.
In VII, the characters are already supernaturally powerful and give up nothing in return. Cloud and Vincent are sorta explainable, they got injected with otherworldly beings. Maybe Aerith and RED XIII too, being unique races and all. But Tifa, Yuffie, Barret, Cid and Caitsith? Not so much.
And traumatic? *** that noise, Rydia had it just as bad. Her mother was killed, THEN her hometown got burned down, and was approached by two fairly intimidating looking men. THEN she was swallowed by Leviathan. She sure as hell didn't lose her memories. Did I mention was like, sevenish when all that happens?
Your points are about game mechanics, and they are completely valid. All the characters in 7 are overpowered.
I didn't say cloud's experiences were the most truamatic ever. But he was too weak to be a soldier... in desperation and shame he became a lowly grunt, and then became a guinea pig for hojo. he spent years (yes, years) stuck in a tube, until he broke out with zack. zack, a powerful, herioc image, everything cloud wanted to be so he became it, repressing memories of his shame and losing his identity.
This is a well formed plot.
In final fantasy 8, halfway through the story the decide to tell you that everyone grew up together, there was no lead in, there was no justification and quite honestly they could have made the story without the plot point entirely, but they decided to cram it in and use the junction with guardian forces as a vehicle for a totally pointless sensationalist plot point.
You can still like 8 more than 7. but it is, in a literary sense, a weak story.
Most of this plot was explained through spin offs, meaning that the story was originally full of plot holes.
Wrong. The spinoffs only took and expanded on the story. Which one of those spinoffs explained something that wast already explained in ff7? none. Playing as zach and learning about sephiroth's rise to power so to speak is pretty irrelevant to the overall plot points. Playing as vincent AFTER the fact does what...? You're making no sense.
What Hojo did was barely explained other than "You got injected with Jenova splooge herp derp"
All of that was explained through Crisis core.
No, it isn't. FF7 simply states that the experiments involve using Jenova's DNA and Mako to enhance physical attributes. The same thing happens in crisis core, nothing different.
サーバ: Sylph
Game: FFXI
Posts: 590
By Sylph.Akibakei 2010-04-30 18:07:17
in my OPINION it is the best ever, and FF8 is the worst. You tend to think that since you masturbate to FF8 that there is no way it can be better than FF7.
I dont need to explain myself. Facts are facts.
Dont confuse "mystery" with "plot-holes." Something not being explained further leaves it open to interpretation, like a lot of GOOD books do. Books are those things with pages that you see at the library.
Cerberus.Ferth
サーバ: Cerberus
Game: FFXI
Posts: 78
By Cerberus.Ferth 2010-04-30 18:08:35
They never explain how cloud got power... they explain how he got mako eyes that allowed him to pull off his zack persona. Whether that gave him power or not is debatable because he was a failed experiment, he didn't meet the expectations they had for him as another attempt at making sephiroth.
And from that, linear's point about the characters being overpowered is reinforced... they are, every character can do anything that any other character can do, all cloud gets is the highest base str.
But that doesn't have bearing on the story its a mechanics issue.
サーバ: Shiva
Game: FFXI
Posts: 23653
By Shiva.Flionheart 2010-04-30 18:08:49
Cerberus.Ferth said: Shiva.Flionheart said:
What Hojo did was barely explained other than "You got injected with Jenova splooge herp derp"
All of that was explained through Crisis core.
I played about halfway through crisis core... I didn't get to the point where they were imprisoned together (if it even gets that far.)
There are cutscenes you can find in 7 that show zack and cloud stuck in the basement of shinra mansion and show them after they've escaped, and how zack dies.
All of that information is available in the game itself. Hell cloud even tells you about it before you can view the cutscenes.
All of the cutscenes were incredibly short and disjointed
Well, I'm going to sleep, feel free to keep posting in this debate, i'll reply once I've woken
(I have no problem with this debate btw, I'm just going to stand my corner because I think VIII gets way too much flack, and VII gets way too much reverence when both had very holey plots, and less than perfect systems.)
サーバ: Shiva
Game: FFXI
Posts: 23653
By Shiva.Flionheart 2010-04-30 18:11:21
Sylph.Akibakei said: in my OPINION it is the best ever, and FF8 is the worst. You tend to think that since you masturbate to FF8 that there is no way it can be better than FF7.
I dont need to explain myself. Facts are facts.
Dont confuse "mystery" with "plot-holes." Something not being explained further leaves it open to interpretation, like a lot of GOOD books do. Books are those things with pages that you see at the library.
I see what you did thar, It's plot holes in FFVIII and Mystery in VII.
Congratulations! you are the typical fan-boy. Pick up your cloud t-shirt at the door.
Also, I like how your avoiding the question i've put forth, and also getting really angry because FFVII is mediocre, gg.
Caitsith.Linear
By Caitsith.Linear 2010-04-30 18:11:26
Actually, Rydia is important to the plot. She's the biggest reason Cecil wanted to repent for everythign he'd done, and ultimately lead to his change into a Paladin.
And the fact that she came back to save his life when Golbez was second away from killing him, even after everything he'd done to her, helped alleviate the guilt and self hate he still carried from his days as a Dark Knight, because she'd managed to forgive him.
This was absolutely key in defeating Zeromus. Had he not changed to a Paladin, he'd never had been able to use the crystal to weaken him into a killable form.
Pandemonium.Kajidourden
サーバ: Pandemonium
Game: FFXI
Posts: 993
By Pandemonium.Kajidourden 2010-04-30 18:11:52
Cerberus.Ferth said: They never explain how cloud got power... they explain how he got mako eyes that allowed him to pull off his zack persona. Whether that gave him power or not is debatable because he was a failed experiment, he didn't meet the expectations they had for him as another attempt at making sephiroth.
And from that, linear's point about the characters being overpowered is reinforced... they are, every character can do anything that any other character can do, all cloud gets is the highest base str.
But that doesn't have bearing on the story its a mechanics issue.
You just kinda contradicted yourself. He gained his abilities from the experimentation. I don't really see how it's debatable since he isn't NEARLY as powerful as Sephiroth, had he been a successful experiment (as sephiroth was) that wouldn't be the case.
サーバ: Shiva
Game: FFXI
Posts: 343
By Shiva.Borealis 2010-04-30 18:14:06
I think BOTH VII and VIII are bad games compared to most of the others. Hell, I even like XII better than them.
Also; LOUD NOISES!
サーバ: Shiva
Game: FFXI
Posts: 23653
By Shiva.Flionheart 2010-04-30 18:15:01
Shiva.Borealis said: I think BOTH VII and VIII are bad games compared to most of the others. Hell, I even like XII better than them.
Also; LOUD NOISES!
You like XII more than any of them >.>
BURN THE WITCH
サーバ: Shiva
Game: FFXI
Posts: 23653
By Shiva.Flionheart 2010-04-30 18:17:19
Asura.Bartimaeus said: 8 was as easy as 7, up until a few notable bosses.
Materia let all your characters do anything, and junctions/mob levels based on your level let you max your characters on the first disc.
I did both, on both games. Personally I just hated 8's graphics. lol I WANT BLOCK HANDS BACK.
And sausage limbs!
Pandemonium.Kajidourden
サーバ: Pandemonium
Game: FFXI
Posts: 993
By Pandemonium.Kajidourden 2010-04-30 18:18:24
Caitsith.Linear said: Actually, Rydia is important to the plot. She's the biggest reason Cecil wanted to repent for everythign he'd done, and ultimately lead to his change into a Paladin.
And the fact that she came back to save his life when Golbez was second away from killing him, even after everything he'd done to her, helped alleviate the guilt and self hate he still carried from his days as a Dark Knight, because she'd managed to forgive him.
This was absolutely key in defeating Zeromus. Had he not changed to a Paladin, he'd never had been able to use the crystal to weaken him into a killable form.
So.... you're saying he wouldn't have had just as much regret for killing an entire village worth of people?
The fact that she shows up to save him did nothing to alleviate his guilt, she had already forgiven him for what happened because she was aware of what really went on, knowing that he was tricked. However the fact that she does save his *** makes her relevant to the story in that one way, had she not been there, he'd be dead.
Cecil was regretting orders he was carrying out even before rydia came along, and admittedly that incident pushed him over the edge, but again, the guilt would be there with or without rydia and the subsequent change to a paladin.
Phoenix.Kojo
Forum Moderator
サーバ: Phoenix
Game: FFXI
Posts: 12308
By Phoenix.Kojo 2010-04-30 18:19:51
Sylph.Akibakei said: in my OPINION it is the best ever, and FF8 is the worst. You tend to think that since you masturbate to FF8 that there is no way it can be better than FF7. I dont need to explain myself. Facts are facts. Dont confuse "mystery" with "plot-holes." Something not being explained further leaves it open to interpretation, like a lot of GOOD books do. Books are those things with pages that you see at the library.
I fap to FFIX, myself.
Caitsith.Linear
By Caitsith.Linear 2010-04-30 18:21:32
Eh, forgot: He also ended up with guilt because she got swallowed by Leviathan when he had sworn to her that he would protect her with his life. Huge relief, I'm sure, when she turned up alive.
サーバ: Shiva
Game: FFXI
Posts: 23653
By Shiva.Flionheart 2010-04-30 18:22:03
Final Fantasy IX is incredible, I think I prefer VIII over it slightly due to it being the first I played, but the characters and system in IX are fap worthy.
VI will always be the best imo though, I've yet to play an FF game that tops it.
サーバ: Odin
Game: FFXI
Posts: 318
By Odin.Ahligieri 2010-04-30 18:22:19
Asura.Bartimaeus said: :D
Can't we all just hate on 12? Pleaseeeeeee! and with that...
Let's make a few things clear. Yes, the main chars of 7 8 9 10 managed to look a little girly.. a little too femme.. but cmon
Vaan.. Vaan.. my female boss at work has the same haircut. Go home!
FFXII coulda been a tad better but overall I liked it. And *** Vaan he isn't the main char to me imo lol.
Phoenix.Kojo
Forum Moderator
サーバ: Phoenix
Game: FFXI
Posts: 12308
By Phoenix.Kojo 2010-04-30 18:23:17
Shiva.Flionheart said: Final Fantasy IX is incredible, I think I prefer VIII over it slightly due to it being the first I played, but the characters and system in IX are fap worthy. VI will always be the best imo though, I've yet to play an FF game that tops it.
Loved VI, it's tied with IX for my fave.
MMO's are excluded, as countless people who play will say they regret ever starting WoW or FFXI (since for the most part they take up so much of your time and become like crack where you're just unable to quit..)
I'm talking about single player games that are just so shitty you can't believe you invested/wasted any time on..
To date, mine is Far Cry 2.. I've never seen such repetivness in a game, literally practically every mission was just driving to a specified spot and blowing something up... Even using the bus, it would take you 10-15 minutes to get there (because the roads wound around to an absolutely ridiculously length and none of the cars could handle going offroad, though the most common (the jeep) was designed for just such a purpose.. It would get suck on rocks and in water that even a BMW would go through without a second thought (and I do mean literally for anyone who's never played it, just ask someone who has.)
|
|