Ok I'm a little perplexed. Last night I was just messing around in Xarcabard shanking Gigas (lvl 46 to 48 I believe) with my 75 Bard. I decided to do Soul Voice & Minuet 3 & 4 for S&G's.
75 Brd
Behemoth knife +1
Dagger skill capped at 242
317 Attack ----- with no songs active
536'ish Attack - with SV & Min 3 & 4
My normal attacks (including crits), as well as my Evisceration's did the EXACT SAME damage across the board. If I remember correctly I was doing 60 to 85 dmg per hit and 108 to 120 per crit and 480 to 660 Evisceration's before AND even after the song buffs.
So the question is this...
Does attack even affect dagger and is it just based off the Dmg of the dagger?
Or is there some sort of damage cap based off the level of the mob vs the Dmg of the weapon in use??