Asura.Saevel said: »
Private servers don't "hurt" retail, but retail players really get tired of evangelicals knocking on our doors and asking us if we've heard about your lord and savior.
After witnessing WoW's demographic shifts from Classic vs. Retail servers, I also do not believe the private servers hurt retail.
Retail players and Classic (Roz FFXI) enjoys like different things about the game. And, to be frank, classic XI is an entirely different game from Retail at this point.
It is like arguing that Old School Runescape is stealing FFXI players. Like, maybe? Some perhaps? But they are really entirely different crowds.
Ya, maybe if NO options exists for classic, private or otherwise, said classic players would go to Retail. But it is just as likely they would play something else.
I have no issues with private servers. I have found that I enjoy Retail more overall (NOT SORTIE tho).
Source for data - "trust me bro" (aka anecdotal)