I'm fairly confident that a BLM can hit harder than a SCH simply due to AMII, that being said, Dot wise SCH it seams would win because he or she would not have to rest as often. Although, all of said arguments above are really meaningless unless a concrete situation is provided, otherwise variables will ruin all data making this debate futile.
As I am genuinely interested in this argument, can someone with both jobs leveled provide screen shots of themselves as BLM and as SCH nuking the same mob naked with the same spell on the same game day, whilst having the same subjob. This would be experiment A (exp. A).
After exp. A, attempt a second experiment (exp. B) in which the same character again with the same variables as stated above nukes a higher level mob tallying the dmg given and stopping said count once MP has run out for both jobs.
In this case I believe SCH will win out.
By doing this, the experiment will remove all variables and from that point on this subject would be void as comparative data will be available for anyone to see.
Thank you in advance to anyone that would take the time to do this and end this argument once and for all.
Official BLM Epeen Vs SCH Epeen Thread!! Keep These Fights Clean!
フォーラム » Everything Else »
Chatterbox
»
Official BLM epeen vs SCH epeen thread!! Keep these fights clean!
Official BLM epeen vs SCH epeen thread!! Keep these fights clean!
Here, complete hume <3.
HQ Ice / Bug+1 / Non / Phantom
Morg / Uggy / Nov / onzozo gob earring
morg / morg / snow / scorc
ixion / sorc / morg / morg
WITH ICE DAY BONUS NO BURN
high 2300s.
I want to see a screen shot of a hume doing 2540+ bs with your gimp gear and no support.
*** liar lol.
HQ Ice / Bug+1 / Non / Phantom
Morg / Uggy / Nov / onzozo gob earring
morg / morg / snow / scorc
ixion / sorc / morg / morg
WITH ICE DAY BONUS NO BURN
high 2300s.
I want to see a screen shot of a hume doing 2540+ bs with your gimp gear and no support.
*** liar lol.
onzozo gob earring is a moldy, *** i forgot what it was called. *** you.
Hasn't it been mentioned that Full Morrigans is not the prime nuke set?
Princemercury said:
Here, complete hume <3. HQ Ice / Bug 1 / Non / Phantom Morg / Uggy / Nov / onzozo gob earring morg / morg / snow / scorc ixion / sorc / morg / morg WITH ICE DAY BONUS NO BURN high 2300s. I want to see a screen shot of a hume doing 2540 bs with your gimp gear and no support. *** liar lol.
I'm a merited taru but... no morrigan no novio hell I use magnetic earring lol. And yes that is spirit lantern kicking my dmg 10%. Though at the cost of 2 int. And I'm forcing ice to proc with obi and relic pants so losing another 13 int and chance to proc a magic crit there. No meds or help
Ramuh.Dasva said:
Megbite said:
stuff
Your methodology is flawed as it doesn't take into account the fact that barring Tiamat you will rarely be called upon to empty your MP pool in the shortest possible amount of time. This is something to establish over long periods of time. Also, it's well established BLM outnukes SCH on a per-nuke basis given no gear or equal gear quality. This is easily deduced from MAB traits and gear availability, tests or formal math are not required. Finally, it's not what the thread is about and quite frankly I doubt many people are interested in having that argument for the 21324239852309485th time.
EDIT: Further: Such arguments are pointless regardless because they assume all your MP goes into nuking. This is almost never true on either job, broadening value beyond pure nuking.
Ramuh.Lilbusta said:
Hasn't it been mentioned that Full Morrigans is not the prime nuke set?
Yeah but I don't have zmitts +1 or the kupo hat.
Ramuh.Lilbusta said:
Hasn't it been mentioned that Full Morrigans is not the prime nuke set?
Yeah but geting higher dmg requires good luck on augments and some pimped out other gear.
Which is why the OP is bullshitting you all.
Ramuh.Dasva said:
Gilgamesh.Nezea said:
Well for starters they have things like day bonuses and INT potions and spirit lanterns. 2317 Freeze II? I've done Blizzard IV for nearly that much on SCH on Iceday without an INT potion. Am I gonna post a million SS to prove it? No. I'm content that myself and my friends know it and I'm not gonna go out of my way to prove it to all the FFXIAHtards *shrug*
Nezea said:
No, I won't post a SS because I didn't take one and i'm not going to go out of my way to do it. Had no help aside from ice day to get that damage. Yes, SCH can one-shot stats - I've done it personally a number of times. No, not all of them can be one-shotted, but SCH can one-shot all the same ones that a BLM can.
Heres why your completely lieing
I have no idea what your race is so I'll assume your taru and it says your 5/5 int merits so I'll give you that. I have 85 base in as a merit taru so you should have 83 if you were taru as a sch/blm and 24MAB.
Your gear shown on here looks like its more for healing/buffing so if I swap out goliard hands for Vmufflers, gol feet for yigit, obi for obi, staff for staff, um for fun throw in morgana body instead of your relic, prism cape for that merciful and mahat pants for the jet seraweels. That should get you 35 MAB and 34int. Give you another 7int from SS and 7 from creme puff puts you at 59MAB and 131int. We will assume you had both weather and day and ebullience. Wiki has has pudding int as 89. Lets say you got a 150int burn on it for -13int to put it at 76.
So dmg forumala will look roughly like this:
D*Staff Bonus*Day | Weather Bonus*MAB / MDB *Target Magic Damage Adjustment=dmg Well and 1.2 for ebullience
Where D= V (dINT * M)
V=506 for blizz4
M=2 for T4 spells
dint=(131-76)
staffbonus=1.15
weatherbonus=1.2
MAB/MDB=1.59
magic adjustment for pudding=1.25
so (506 (131-76)*2)*1.15*1.2*1.59*1.25*1.2= 2027.
Now to get to 2317 with just more int(assuming you don't hit the point of int only being half as effective also assume you haven't already or even capped dint) you could do it with another 44int assuming your taru more if your not. Could also get the same with another 22-23MAB. And of course this is all assuming that I completely pimp your gear out that isn't well pimp out for dmg since morgana is kinda silly normally. Or tl;dr that dmg is impossible with his gear solo even if you are taru with super pimped gear without an int potion proccing rather high
This is why I said "nearly". In any case it's been months since I took my SCH to puddings and as I said I don't take SS of it, so it really is a rough estimate. I'm confident it was about 2100. Might have got magic crit, I don't really remember. Either way, that's high enough to compete with the majority of BLMs' AM2. I'm not claiming it will do exactly as much as a perfectly equipped BLM. Yeah, my BLM's AM2 will -slightly- beat my SCH's T4. Besides that, it's very rare I encounter a BLM as well equipped as my own anyway.
If I swap out morggy pants with AF2 pants my damage is a LITTLE higher. but that's if the ice day bonus kicks in w/o obi.
Princemercury said:
If I swap out morggy pants with AF2 pants my damage is a LITTLE higher. but that's if the ice day bonus kicks in w/o obi.
If you're doing that, you should also swap out feet for yigit and head for.. I dunno, demon helm+1?
This just in: Taru with same gear nukes mid 2400. So *** off Korpg lmao.
Blazza, yes, just stating AF2 pants are a little better than full morg set.
Nezea said:
This is why I said "nearly". In any case it's been months since I took my SCH to puddings and as I said I don't take SS of it, so it really is a rough estimate. I'm confident it was about 2100. Might have got magic crit, I don't really remember. Either way, that's high enough to compete with the majority of BLMs' AM2. I'm not claiming it will do exactly as much as a perfectly equipped BLM. Yeah, my BLM's AM2 will -slightly- beat my SCH's T4. Besides that, it's very rare I encounter a BLM as well equipped as my own anyway.
If you are taru and you had those perfect conditions and got magic crit its conceivable with that near perfect gear set to hit 2100+ blizz4. It's also conceivable that a blm with gear that is just as good...well actually can easily get better will do more. Just the jobtrait/merits from blm come close to closing the ebullience factor. Add on things like being able to wear morrigans or sorc ring it just kinda becomes silly.
Also give me your novio!!!!
Augments don't take luck. They just take persistence and gil. You can eventually get the augments if you have the time and money to spend. When I see a taru with both jobs and the best possible gear post SS on both puddings and HNM then I'll take it as facts.
I don't understand why people throw their own bag of ***in here when no one is wearing the exact same gear or posting SS's to back their statements/opinions.
I don't understand why people throw their own bag of ***in here when no one is wearing the exact same gear or posting SS's to back their statements/opinions.
No, a BLM could not hit 2100 Blizzard 4 there without help. SCH T4 is already very comparable to BLM T4 without Ebullience. There is nothing BLM can do to make up for that extra 20 MAB.
Nezea said:
No, a BLM could not hit 2100 Blizzard 4 there without help. SCH T4 is already very comparable to BLM T4 without Ebullience. There is nothing BLM can do to make up for that extra 20 MAB.
Yeah huh, we can all lie like Korpg.
I don't know about you guys but i'm pretty amused that it went from BLM's epeening the SCH's with their damage to being BLM vs BLM now it seems.
The thread is apparently now augments vs player race vs gear and my BLM can do higher than your BLM.
-.-
The thread is apparently now augments vs player race vs gear and my BLM can do higher than your BLM.
-.-
Yeah but it's Morrigan set bonus which makes it so good, as soon as you break the set you lose the extra 5 MAB that makes the feet and head worth wearing. You know this of course, but just saying that if you're swapping in AF2 pants, swapping in yigit feet and something on the head should make the damage better even without the weather proc... shouldn't it?
Princemercury said:
This just in: Taru with same gear nukes mid 2400. So *** off Korpg lmao.
Same gear as who? I'm pretty sure both you if you have full morrigan and Korpg have better gear then me and I still did this...
Ramuh.Dasva said:
Even swapping enchantment out for phantom would still put me at around 2350. Novio alone would put me around 2450. Since I'm using relic pants morigan wont really matter cept body since 5MAB and 8 int slightly beats out my 6MAB 3int body. I guess mid 2400s seems right if your only getting day or weather to proc without things like int potion or spirit lantern or outside help and your really pimped.
But my taru is better than your taru because I chose face 2 option!
Clinpachi said:
I don't know about you guys but i'm pretty amused that it went from BLM's epeening the SCH's with their damage to being BLM vs BLM now it seems.
The thread is apparently now augments vs player race vs gear and my BLM can do higher than your BLM.
-.-
The thread is apparently now augments vs player race vs gear and my BLM can do higher than your BLM.
-.-
OP stated no fibbing in the 1st post.
What a hypocrite so *** this stupid *** thread.
Odin.Blazza said:
Yeah but it's Morrigan set bonus which makes it so good, as soon as you break the set you lose the extra 5 MAB that makes the feet and head worth wearing. You know this of course, but just saying that if you're swapping in AF2 pants, swapping in yigit feet and something on the head should make the damage better even without the weather proc... shouldn't it?
Yes, you are right for the 2nd time :P. Just saying AF2 set is > Morggy.
Nezea said:
No, a BLM could not hit 2100 Blizzard 4 there without help. SCH T4 is already very comparable to BLM T4 without Ebullience. There is nothing BLM can do to make up for that extra 20 MAB.
Actually you get +20% from ebullience which is better then 20MAB. While we get 18-22MAB more just by being a blm no gear.
2100 blizz4 you say? I bet you I could with novio and a better weskit. Or just get ice to proc while still wearing witch sash and get magic crit.
Edit: quick math shows that I can almost reach 2100 blizz4 with just adding novio lol.
t(-.-t)
[thread]
-A good SCH can easily outdo a BLM's T4.
-A good SCH's T4 can be slightly outdone by a good BLM's AM2
[/thread]
[thread]
-A good SCH can easily outdo a BLM's T4.
-A good SCH's T4 can be slightly outdone by a good BLM's AM2
[/thread]
If XI were real, and I were a girl, and I lived in Vanadiel, and if I were a BLM, I would give a hand job to get Ebu on my BLM.
I have these things and I am telling you a BLM will not nuke 2100 T4 on a pudding.
Yeah most a natural BLM can pump out is 1800ish.
All FFXI content and images © 2002-2025 SQUARE ENIX CO., LTD. FINAL
FANTASY is a registered trademark of Square Enix Co., Ltd.