The concept to you is the same, but the concept to the lender is sort of different.
People tend to have lots of ancient currency on hand, because you need to have a lot to turn in. I don't fish, but I can't think of a reason why anyone would have piles of fish just sitting around. That's a problem. Am I going to want to meet up and give you 200 fish every day until you leave? Not really. Plus, I don't want to keep updating what you owe all the time.
Also, while many relic loans are based on reputation, many people do at least offer some kind of collateral. You do not. (You could offer up some of that dyna currency, though.)
Another difference is that by the time people are ready to ask for a relic loan, they are usually pretty broke. You just said you spent all your gil on currency. What you could have done is spend that gil on fish, and then bought currency when you got back. (It doesn't look like you finished Mandau yet, but even if you did, what good does IT do while you are gone?)
Also, people have varying opinions on fishbotting. Some people hate it, some people don't care, other people are big fans. That might cause some problems. Personally, I don't care, but it does make me a little jealous knowing that you are not only making a ton of gil while on vacation, but that you're trying to make TWO tons of gil while on vacation. I don't think many people are motivated to lend anything to someone they perceive as perfectly and easily capable of obtaining on their own.
Finally,
Phoenix.Gaiarorshack said:
»i don't see how this is much different from relic loans really.
im making the gil every day. im just asking for a way to increase my fish in the period up to my vacation so i have a better chance of getting an extra ebisu before my vacation.
clearly for some people its hard to understand that
fish you fish + fish you buy + fish on credits
is more/faster than
fish you fish + fish you buy
it isn't that hard math guys, really.
You kind of sound like... someone I wouldn't want to lend anything to, anyway.