Only thing I don't like about the rating system is that your pics are auto sorted by rating. I'd rathe rpick the order myself, but other than that idc about the rating itself.
I always thought that the rate-downs were a good indicator to the general population's opinion of what was said.
Going to disagree, mildly.
Honestly, if what you said here were true, Terminus, then we would see an even distribution of rate-ups and rate-downs.
There's no way that's reality.
The rate-down feature is pretty much useless. It doesn't really convey anything. Someone who rates-down could be just in a bad mood, or not had any sex for a few months, or recently been grounded by their momma ... or maybe they don't like your avatar, or your name, or your grammar ... or maybe they didn't like the opinion someone expressed about a sensitive but unrelated topic 3 months ago ... and some people even rate-down because a couple others have already rated-down a post, and they just want to "fit in".
Like I said, because there are an infinite number of (mostly stupid) reasons someone could rate-down, it conveys nothing.
So, since it conveys nothing, and there are no concrete consequences established for excessive rate-downs here ... I'd re-iterate that it's a pointless function.
And, I'd ask, echoing the OP, why do we have the rate-down feature?
I rate down people because it causes much anger in general.
I'm not pulling any punches about it, if you complain about being rated down or even mention the rating system in such a way that would make me assume you don't like being rated down, I'll rate you down to see what happens.
I'll also rate down people I dislike and people who's opinions I don't agree with.
I'll also rate down people to make things balanced, seeing -9 on a post really bugs me so I have to rate it down so it hits -10 and my OCD doesn't flare up.
As for screenshots:
If you don't like the comments, disable comments. If you don't like being rated down disable ratings.
Post what you want as long as it follows website rules, and honestly laugh at the people who get that angry over you posting a SS from a different game.
I rate down people because it causes much anger in general.
If you complain about being rated down or even mention the rating system in such a way that would make me assume you don't like being rated down, I'll rate you down to see what happens.
I'll also rate down people I dislike and people who's opinions I don't agree with.
I'll also rate down people to make things balanced, seeing -9 on a post really bugs me so I have to rate it down so it hits -10 and my OCD doesn't flare up.
Flionheart did a fine job of further illustrating my point.
Well done.
Just using him as (prime) example, there's so many reasons why he clicks the rate-down button, that the purpose of the rate-down button becomes diluted and generally pointless.
Thus, as previously asked, why not remove the rate-down feature? Removing it can not do any harm, and there's at least a chance it could do good.
Plus, there's a good chance we could help Flionheart's mental health, since there wouldn't be any more -9's to make his OCD flare up.
I rate down people because it causes much anger in general.
If you complain about being rated down or even mention the rating system in such a way that would make me assume you don't like being rated down, I'll rate you down to see what happens.
I'll also rate down people I dislike and people who's opinions I don't agree with.
I'll also rate down people to make things balanced, seeing -9 on a post really bugs me so I have to rate it down so it hits -10 and my OCD doesn't flare up.
Flionheart did a fine job of further illustrating my point.
Well done.
Just using him as (prime) example, there's so many reasons why he clicks the rate-down button, that the purpose of the rate-down button becomes diluted and generally pointless.
Thus, as previously asked, why not remove the rate-down feature? Removing it can not do any harm, and there's at least a chance it could do good.
Plus, there's a good chance we could help Flionheart's mental health, since there wouldn't be any more -9's to make his OCD flare up.
Seems like a no-brainer to me.
The weak willed elanabelle, I know you couldn't resist reading my posts.
I'm going to go ahead and throw out there that the karma/rating system in general is a bad feature in my personal opinion. A report button sure, but karma/rating just seems to lead to troll/flame bait more often than it seems to do anything good. I wouldn't mind if it was removed. This is just my personal opinion though.
I'm going to go ahead and throw out there that the karma/rating system in general is a bad feature in my personal opinion. A report button sure, but karma/rating just seems to lead to troll/flame bait more often than it seems to do anything good. I wouldn't mind if it was removed. This is just my personal opinion though.
Could just add an option not to be able to view ratings. So the people who don't want to participate don't have to.
Also agree with that too. I mean ratings don't bother me personally, but seeing as people take them so seriously maybe it's best if they remove them, or just make rate ups available.
Oh and I'll also rate up to make my OCD stop flaring up.
Like OP was at -11 now she's at -10.
All is well.
Kind of guilty of this, too. Even on like item comments. I just can't stand the odd numbers.
So, people that think they only get rate downs because people are stalking them or hate them or w/e... it's not always the case. Could just be the person clicking that - or + is cuckoo for cocoa puffs.
Maybe I'm just because I'm in a bad mood or something today, but I'm finally going to speak my mind about a couple of things on this site. I expect a lot of people are going to gain negative opinions of me after this, but there are two things that I really would like to see changed on this site.
1. Screenshots. It's been brought up on a few occasions, typically people complaining about how much hate WoW-related screenshots get and stuff like that, and a moderator always steps in saying "We allow it so all you haters cut it out". But the question is why do you allow it? I'm sure lots of people like myself are indifferent, but if so many people get so worked-up over it, rating the screenshots 1/10, rating-down positive comments towards the screenshots, and both parties making topics that end up as nothing more than locked flame-wars, then why not just stop it already? It's a problem of leniency, which is obvious in how the screenshot moderators appear to allow pretty much anything bad or otherwise controversial through the filter. I just looked through the recent screenshots and saw an image from Facebook making fun of a guy whose cat just died. That's not humorous, that's horrible taste. That's like the Family Guy joke where Peter makes fun of the little kid crying for his deceased mother taunting, "[name] misses his mo-mmy, [name] misses his mo-mmy!". And there's other screenshots that shouldn't be allowed too. Why are obvious troll images whose sole purpose of being there is to piss people off not removed? Why are screenshots of peoples' equipment with the character's name for the sole purpose of making fun of them not removed? If you're going to moderate screenshots, you seriously shouldn't allow images through whose sole intents are to harm people.
2. Rate-downs. I really just don't like them. Never before have I ever seen a system on a web site that has been so negative without any single benefit. They scare people from making posts, they get under peoples' skin, and they allow people to just go on rampages and just rate everyone down. The point of the rate-ups/rate-downs is to allow people to agree or disagree, but I don't think that's proper forum etiquette if they're not obligated to describe why they disagree. I see no reason to get rid of rate-ups, but rate-downs need to go. I don't know how many times I see a comment I've made that was rated down and ask "Why did someone do that?". It doesn't help anything when people are left there wondering what they may have said wrong. I'd gladly fix my post up or perhaps rebut your argument if you had one presented, but you just hit [-], then all I know is that there's at least one person out there who disagrees with me and I can never know why. There's a reason why only a small handful of forums ever use rate-ups and rate-downs. Forums are about free speech, and writing a huge post just to exit out of the window because I think that someone, somewhere out there might disagree with me is just wrong. If you continue to allow rate-ups, then you can still distinguish between good posts and not-good posts, but rate-downs are just bad to have. As long as people are not obligated to rate up or rate down every single post, the system is broken anyway.
That being said, I expect to have a -30 on this thread before I even come back to check on this thread. But if you're going to rate me down, PLEASE at least give me the courtesy of explaining to me why you disagree.
TL;DR-- If you're going to moderate screenshots, make the filter a little tighter. And rate-downs should simply be removed. Thank you for reading.
bolded-opinion
i fail to see why you don't undestand that they really only moderate legaly questionable material and probably gore. as for the rate downs, grow up. there will always be people who dont agree with you for no reason. if you wont speak your mind because you're afraid of what peope may think then you are pathetic and should go find some *** self confidence.
Op never stated it wasn't opinion, whats wrong with opinions again? even your post is an opinion.
and like OP said:
"Forums are about free speech"
I was talking about the "that's horrible taste" bold, I'm sorry I was making the comment from my phone and I didn't see that other parts were bolded in OP.
the problem with opinions is that people attempt to make policies based upon subjectivity, basically here:
basically I was saying for the OP to grow up and grow some self confidence while they're at it.
I completely agree with Elanabelle and Darki on this, this forum is full of ignorant rude selfish idiots, who just spend their time waiting to cause an argument with someone for the fun of it.
The rate up and down feature in posts is HELP I AM TRAPPED IN 2006 PLEASE SEND A TIME MACHINE, i have not seen another website which has this kind of system, and having been a part of a number of different forums, usually they have rules, and usually the admins care enough to put rules in place so the people who come to visit their forums, do not get upset and harassed by other members.
Every single time i come onto this forum, and make a new thread, some smartass comes in and starts on me, Why??? They dont even know me, usually all im doing is trying to find out some information, or im trying to make a useful thread for the community so players can be read it and think, well you know what i never knew that, im glad i come to this website.
Whenever someone gets upset in this forum, and try to express their concern, they get this STOP CRYIN! GROW UP! Get a sense of humour etc etc, the list of insults goes on and on and nothing is ever done to stop this.
Personally this website has helped me a great deal, and i have contributed to the forums with useful guides which got high praise, but there is always going to be some idiot on here who turns around and says to me, YOUR A MORAN BECAUSE YOU DON'T KNOW HOW TO SPELL! XD
Scragg, Jaerik, why exactly do you allow your forum to be filled with so much hate? Do you enjoy watching people insult each other? If this was any other forum everyone would have left by now, but because this is a website for a popular game, people come here to get help with it, not to be abused.
The fact you can turn on and off screenshots ratings, thats fine with me, people generally rate the screenshot on how good it is compared to the rest they have seen, but when it comes to posts its completely not needed at all, there is no good reason why any post should be rated up or down, its a useless feature which never helps anyone.
Some people generally get more upset then others, thats life, thats how human feelings work, no one on this website can expect someone to relax and accept everything is fine when they just been called an idiot for no reason, where is the logic?
This website is very well built, but when it comes to rules and some general order, there is NONE! And that is what is wrong with FFXIAH.com. You may find a lot more people will come here if you added some rules.
I completely agree with Elanabelle and Darki on this, this forum is full of ignorant rude selfish idiots, who just spend their time waiting to cause an argument with someone for the fun of it.
The rate up and down feature in posts is HELP I AM TRAPPED IN 2006 PLEASE SEND A TIME MACHINE, i have not seen another website which has this kind of system, and having been a part of a number of different forums, usually they have rules, and usually the admins care enough to put rules in place so the people who come to visit their forums, do not get upset and harassed by other members.
Every single time i come onto this forum, and make a new thread, some smartass comes in and starts on me, Why??? They dont even know me, usually all im doing is trying to find out some information, or im trying to make a useful thread for the community so players can be read it and think, well you know what i never knew that, im glad i come to this website.
Whenever someone gets upset in this forum, and try to express their concern, they get this STOP CRYIN! GROW UP! Get a sense of humour etc etc, the list of insults goes on and on and nothing is ever done to stop this.
Personally this website has helped me a great deal, and i have contributed to the forums with useful guides which got high praise, but there is always going to be some idiot on here who turns around and says to me, YOUR A MORAN BECAUSE YOU DON'T KNOW HOW TO SPELL! XD
Scragg, Jaerik, why exactly do you allow your forum to be filled with so much hate? Do you enjoy watching people insult each other? If this was any other forum everyone would have left by now, but because this is a website for a popular game, people come here to get help with it, not to be abused.
The fact you can turn on and off screenshots ratings, thats fine with me, people generally rate the screenshot on how good it is compared to the rest they have seen, but when it comes to posts its completely not needed at all, there is no good reason why any post should be rated up or down, its a useless feature which never helps anyone.
Some people generally get more upset then others, thats life, thats how human feelings work, no one on this website can expect someone to relax and accept everything is fine when they just been called an idiot for no reason, where is the logic?
This website is very well built, but when it comes to rules and some general order, there is NONE! And that is what is wrong with FFXIAH.com. You may find a lot more people will come here if you added some rules.
Glad you know all of us so well. Personally, I thought I was decently intelligent and pretty damn nice.. but I see now that I am not, and that everyone on here is the same. Kewl.
I completely agree with Elanabelle and Darki on this, this forum is full of ignorant rude selfish idiots, who just spend their time waiting to cause an argument with someone for the fun of it.
The rate up and down feature in posts is HELP I AM TRAPPED IN 2006 PLEASE SEND A TIME MACHINE, i have not seen another website which has this kind of system, and having been a part of a number of different forums, usually they have rules, and usually the admins care enough to put rules in place so the people who come to visit their forums, do not get upset and harassed by other members.
Every single time i come onto this forum, and make a new thread, some smartass comes in and starts on me, Why??? They dont even know me, usually all im doing is trying to find out some information, or im trying to make a useful thread for the community so players can be read it and think, well you know what i never knew that, im glad i come to this website.
Whenever someone gets upset in this forum, and try to express their concern, they get this STOP CRYIN! GROW UP! Get a sense of humour etc etc, the list of insults goes on and on and nothing is ever done to stop this.
Personally this website has helped me a great deal, and i have contributed to the forums with useful guides which got high praise, but there is always going to be some idiot on here who turns around and says to me, YOUR A MORAN BECAUSE YOU DON'T KNOW HOW TO SPELL! XD
Scragg, Jaerik, why exactly do you allow your forum to be filled with so much hate? Do you enjoy watching people insult each other? If this was any other forum everyone would have left by now, but because this is a website for a popular game, people come here to get help with it, not to be abused.
The fact you can turn on and off screenshots ratings, thats fine with me, people generally rate the screenshot on how good it is compared to the rest they have seen, but when it comes to posts its completely not needed at all, there is no good reason why any post should be rated up or down, its a useless feature which never helps anyone.
Some people generally get more upset then others, thats life, thats how human feelings work, no one on this website can expect someone to relax and accept everything is fine when they just been called an idiot for no reason, where is the logic?
This website is very well built, but when it comes to rules and some general order, there is NONE! And that is what is wrong with FFXIAH.com. You may find a lot more people will come here if you added some rules.
you do need to grow the *** up, and just a flaw in your logic:
there are plenty of people on here who don't play anymore and yet still come on here on the daily, and not just the trolls.
there's nothing "wrong" with the website in general, unless you're having technical difficulties, if you don't like how they moderate, then go QQ by yourself, in your hole. Suck on your thumb while you're at it.
I completely agree with Elanabelle and Darki on this, this forum is full of ignorant rude selfish idiots, who just spend their time waiting to cause an argument with someone for the fun of it.
The rate up and down feature in posts is HELP I AM TRAPPED IN 2006 PLEASE SEND A TIME MACHINE, i have not seen another website which has this kind of system, and having been a part of a number of different forums, usually they have rules, and usually the admins care enough to put rules in place so the people who come to visit their forums, do not get upset and harassed by other members.
Every single time i come onto this forum, and make a new thread, some smartass comes in and starts on me, Why??? They dont even know me, usually all im doing is trying to find out some information, or im trying to make a useful thread for the community so players can be read it and think, well you know what i never knew that, im glad i come to this website.
Whenever someone gets upset in this forum, and try to express their concern, they get this STOP CRYIN! GROW UP! Get a sense of humour etc etc, the list of insults goes on and on and nothing is ever done to stop this.
Personally this website has helped me a great deal, and i have contributed to the forums with useful guides which got high praise, but there is always going to be some idiot on here who turns around and says to me, YOUR A MORAN BECAUSE YOU DON'T KNOW HOW TO SPELL! XD
Scragg, Jaerik, why exactly do you allow your forum to be filled with so much hate? Do you enjoy watching people insult each other? If this was any other forum everyone would have left by now, but because this is a website for a popular game, people come here to get help with it, not to be abused.
The fact you can turn on and off screenshots ratings, thats fine with me, people generally rate the screenshot on how good it is compared to the rest they have seen, but when it comes to posts its completely not needed at all, there is no good reason why any post should be rated up or down, its a useless feature which never helps anyone.
Some people generally get more upset then others, thats life, thats how human feelings work, no one on this website can expect someone to relax and accept everything is fine when they just been called an idiot for no reason, where is the logic?
This website is very well built, but when it comes to rules and some general order, there is NONE! And that is what is wrong with FFXIAH.com. You may find a lot more people will come here if you added some rules.
Glad you know all of us so well. Personally, I thought I was decently intelligent and pretty damn nice.. but I see now that I am not, and that everyone on here is the same. Kewl.
Exactly, hence my "Son I am derp" picture.
You can't act like a *** then expect other people not to treat you like one.
Glad you know all of us so well. Personally, I thought I was decently intelligent and pretty damn nice.. but I see now that I am not, and that everyone on here is the same. Kewl.
Kind of disappointing, Bluespoons.
Yes, I would agree that you are decently intelligent and kind.
So ... I highly doubt Kylos was referring to you, at all.
However, there are a lot of ignorant/rude/selfish idiots in these forums ... a point that I've made several times over the past months.
Just because someone makes a generalizing statement doesn't automatically mean you're one of the guilty parties. And, being a decently intelligent person, you should know that, right?
Nah blue, your taking that too literally, i have talked to some real good people on here too, like i said before i did guides for people which they really appreciated and thanked me for.
When i said full of, i didn't mean 100% of people, or i would have said.. Every single person who posts in the forums are idiots, which i did not :) Sorry if you took that the wring way
Glad you know all of us so well. Personally, I thought I was decently intelligent and pretty damn nice.. but I see now that I am not, and that everyone on here is the same. Kewl.
Kind of disappointing, Bluespoons.
Yes, I would agree that you are decently intelligent and kind.
So ... I highly doubt Kylos was referring to you, at all.
However, there are a lot of ignorant/rude/selfish idiots in these forums ... a point that I've made several times over the past months.
Just because someone makes a generalizing statement doesn't automatically mean you're one of the guilty parties. And, being a decently intelligent person, you should know that, right?
Shut the *** up elanabelle. Go cry about how the forums don't meet your specific tastes.