What the *** at this thread?
You cannot prove something without data collected via a
controlled, scientific method: this means all of your tests on Earthsday will have to be performed at the same moon phase (time is a bit of a stretch, but moon phase MIGHT affect it - you can't discount this).
On topic though @OP: At level 70, you should be more than capable of meleeing Maat down. If you cannot, then it suggests that your gear is severely lacking and you should take this opportunity to improve it.
You need good Daggers, a Bomb Core at the least to use when not pulling, Optical Hat would be nice because it's good for WS until you get Hecatomb/Enkidu Cap, Chivalrous Chain at the very least for the neck, 2x Attack Earring at least, Dusk Gloves at 72 (Battle Gloves until then I guess unless I'm missing something), 2x ACC ring (macro the DEX ones into SA and AGI into TA), NQ Amemet or HQ, At least a Headlong Belt, Bravo's Subligar and Dusk Ledelsens at 72.
EDIT: Also, WAR sub at 37 will help at 75.
Sound like a lot of work? If so, it's because you haven't been doing it as you go along which'll make it stack up against you. WELL worth the effort (and learning to make money is a valuable skill in itself).