Monster Rearing - Mandragora

2.5 Korrigan - Watermelon made it angry. :( (Also, no evolve messages )

So with these developments from everyone yesterday, we need to figure out the trick to evolve Mandragoras into Elders. I am assuming Ake-Ome comes from Lycopodiums, so we will have to wait a while before being able to try that (with Saruta Oranges?) Citrillus might come from Pachypodiums (after Korrigans?)

Lycopodium Interations
Poke - Stares off into the distance
Pet - Surprisingly not worthless
Slap - Strongly Resonated (Yesterday I found that Liquids strongly resonate too)

New Foods to try on Adenium 2.5 stars+
Watermelon
Ambrosia - Tried this 10/4, no go
Amrita - I tried this, didn't work
Saruta Orange - Unagihito tried

"Find the Elder Mandragora!" - Left to try on 2.5 star+ Adult Mandragora (I am removing them as they are used)
Crystals = Light Cluster, Lightning Cluster, Water Cluster, Wind Cluster, Gem of the North, Gem of the South, Gem of the West
Fish = Bastore Sardine, Bibiki Urchin, Noble Lady
Fruit = Acorn, Chestnut, Dragon Fruit, Faerie Apple, Kitron, Millioncorn, Persikos, Pine Nuts, Yagudo Cherry
Fungi = Agaricus, Coral Fungus, Reishi Mushroom, Sobbing Fungus
Greens = Habaneros, La Theine Cabbage, Moko Grass
Liquids = Ahriman's Tears, Yellow Ginseng
Meats = Buffalo Meat, Giant Sheep Meat, Hare Meat, Hydra Meat, Warthog Meat
Seeds = Blue Peas, Popoto, Vomp Carrot, Walnut, Zegham Carrot

I tried an Earth Cluster today. It has been reported that the following also did not give an evolution message: Holy Water, Ambrosia, Amrita, Saruta Orange, Watermelon

"Find the Korrigan Evolution!" - Left to try on 2.5 star+ Korrigan (I am removing them as they are used)
Crystals = Earth Cluster, Light Cluster, Lightning Cluster, Water Cluster, Wind Cluster, Gem of the North, Gem of the South, Gem of the West
Fish = Bastore Sardine, Bibiki Urchin, Noble Lady
Fruit = Acorn, Chestnut, Dragon Fruit, Faerie Apple, Kitron, Millioncorn, Persikos, Pine Nuts, Yagudo Cherry
Fungi = Agaricus, Coral Fungus, Reishi Mushroom, Sobbing Fungus
Greens = Habaneros, La Theine Cabbage, Moko Grass
Liquids = Ahriman's Tears, Elixer, Yellow Ginseng
Meats = Buffalo Meat, Giant Sheep Meat, Hare Meat, Hydra Meat, Warthog Meat
Seeds = Blue Peas, Popoto, Vomp Carrot, Walnut, Zegham Carrot

None of the new foods worked on Korrigans.
Watermelon - Unagihito tried
Ambrosia - Znitch tried
Amrita - Unagihito tried
Saruta Orange - I tried this, didnt work

Can scratch Elixir off the list for adult to elder. Strongly resonated, but nothing else. (:

Here is where we are at today.

Adenium
Tried Ambrosia today on my 2.5 star Adenium, didnt work. We still need to try Watermelon, and then we will begin with a list like below...

"Find the Elder Mandragora!" - Left to try on 2.5 star+ Adult Mandragora (I am removing them as they are used)
Crystals = Light Cluster, Lightning Cluster, Water Cluster, Wind Cluster, Gem of the North, Gem of the South, Gem of the West
Fish = Bastore Sardine, Bibiki Urchin, Noble Lady
Fruit = Acorn, Chestnut, Dragon Fruit, Faerie Apple, Kitron, Millioncorn, Persikos, Pine Nuts, Yagudo Cherry
Fungi = Agaricus, Coral Fungus, Reishi Mushroom, Sobbing Fungus
Greens = Habaneros, La Theine Cabbage, Moko Grass
Liquids = Ahriman's Tears, Yellow Ginseng
Meats = Buffalo Meat, Giant Sheep Meat, Hare Meat, Hydra Meat, Warthog Meat
Seeds = Blue Peas, Popoto, Vomp Carrot, Walnut, Zegham Carrot

10/4 - I tried a Moon Carrot, because of login campaign. No-go.

"Find the Korrigan Evolution!" - Left to try on 2.5 star+ Korrigan (I am removing them as they are used)
Crystals = Earth Cluster, Light Cluster, Lightning Cluster, Water Cluster, Wind Cluster, Gem of the North, Gem of the South, Gem of the West
Fish = Bastore Sardine, Bibiki Urchin, Noble Lady
Fruit = Acorn, Chestnut, Dragon Fruit, Faerie Apple, Kitron, Millioncorn, Persikos, Pine Nuts, Yagudo Cherry
Fungi = Agaricus, Coral Fungus, Reishi Mushroom, Sobbing Fungus
Greens = Habaneros, La Theine Cabbage, Moko Grass
Liquids = Ahriman's Tears, Elixer, Yellow Ginseng
Meats = Buffalo Meat, Giant Sheep Meat, Hare Meat, Hydra Meat, Warthog Meat
Seeds = Blue Peas, Popoto, Vomp Carrot, Walnut, Zegham Carrot

10/4 - I tried a Moon Carrot, because of login campaign. No-go.

Watermelon on my 2.5 star Adenium made it visibly angry, no message.

JP Wiki reported that Elder Mandys are a natural evolution of mandys.

Buffalo meat:

2.5 star Korrigan strongly resonated

2.5 star Adenium surprisingly not worthless

no additional messages

Elder Adenium & Elder Mandragora
If I had to guess, I would say Elder Adenium comes naturally from an Adenium (Now that we know/assume an "Elder Mandragora" is natural from a Mandragora).

Pachypodium must be an evolution of Korrigans due to different "species", so we should try to figure that out. Citrillus is probably an evolution from a Pachypodium via Watermelon, and Ake-Ome from a Lycopodium with a Saruta Orange. If this is the case, they added Ambrosia and Amrita just to troll us.

10/5 - Tried Earth Cluster today.

Moko grass:

2.5 star Korrigan didn't go over too well

2.5 star Adenium didn't go over too well

no additional messages

If anyone has any suggestions from the list Funk compiled, I'll try those first

Lycopodium Memento gives Lycopodium flower. Yay .5 star memento.

Price?

Sorry, 576.

10/6 I tried a Light Cluster today

10/7 Bastore Sardine


Try a Yellow Ginseng on a Korrigan

Ahriman's Tears - 3 Star Korrigan and 2.5 Star Adenium: Both Resonated Strongly, no message


Oof. Didn't realize how impossible this is to get at short notice. Doesn't seem any of the raised chocobos I have access to posesses burrow or bore. I'll keep shouting and make a plea on the Shiva forum.

Got a message that someone tried all of the Fungi, and nothing.

10/8 8:30PM Central - I tried an Elixir today, and removed Yellow Ginseng.

10/9 10:20AM Central - Tried Hydra Meat today.

A very kind player sent me a Yellow Ginseng, tested it on my 3 star Korrigan: Visibly angry, no message

Thank God that's not it

~Updated below~

Bibiki Urchin - 3 Star Korrigan and 3 Star Adenium: surprisingly not worthless, no message

So after reviewing again, nobody has reportedly tried an Ambrosia or Amrita on a 3.0 star Korrigan (only on a 2.5 star). If we exhaust this list for the Korrigan attempts, I will be trying that first.

Hare meat - 3 star Korrigan - Strongly resonated, no message.

Had some Amrita clogging my inventory, so I used those today. Strongly resonated, no messages on 3 star Korrigan and Adenium. I'll get back to the list tomorrow.

~Updated next page~

JP wiki now reports that pachypodium is a natural evolution of Korrigans.

So Ake-Ome and Citrullus are the missing ones? Lycopodium into Ake-Ome and Pachypodium into Citrullus based on cheer effects from Cory's post on page 1? Probably Saruta Orange and Watermelon for evolution foods, or just more natural evolutions... Amrita and Ambrosia might just be trolls like you said.

Sounds like that is the case. My korrigan has been 3 stars for awhile now, and with the evolution campaign starting today it'll probably evolve soon.

Ill keep chipping away at this list in the meantime.

Is there a page that has known paths? I just upgraded my Mandragora to Lycopodium using distilled water. I am sure this has been known for awhile, but I can't seem to find the page with the known paths.

Everything we know is here (scroll down to mandragoras)

https://www.bg-wiki.com/bg/Monster_Rearing#Monster_Rearing_Rank_4

PS: Even though we are assuming these natural evolutions of Elder Mandragora, Elder Adenium, and now Pachypodium, we still need confirmations. Please post when you get an evolution.

Elder Mandy is natural: