Kidney Knife Vs Corsair's Knife

[updated]I decided to stick with the Corsair's Knife after about an hour of using the Kidney Knife. The critical hits didn't kick in that often and the damage it did was significantly lower.

I'm currently using 2 Corsair's knife on THF but I'm debating on switching over to Kidney Knife. Does anyone have any recommendations or experience with the Kidney knife? Does the critical hits make up for the loss of attack?

Corsair's knife will do the most damage per swing, but it's DPS isn't all that good at your level. Also, attack doesn't really give as much benefit to SATA which is your main role in a party. Your goal should be to have 100TP every time SATA is ready and to do that you want low delay weapons. I see you're a 58 Hume THF. I'd recommend the following setup:

Mainhand:
1st Choice: Chicken Knife 21/176 (Additonal Effect: Flee is a novelty, but kind of fun.)
2nd Choice: Beetle Knife +1 21/190 AGI +2
3rd Choice: Darksteel Jambiya +1 21/194 Acc +2
4th Choice: Darksteel Baselard +1 21/190
5th Choice: Corsair's Knife 21/206 Atk +10

Offhand:
1st Choice: Kidney Dagger 18/183 Critical +5%
2nd Choice: Hornetneedle 16/150 DEX +1 AGI +1

These are just my opinions. I hope they help.

New necro record!?

put it in teh record books!!!!