Fenrir.Gradd said:
The answer to Guillotine is Torcleaver, if your using a scythe your doing it wrong!
Ive always hated scythe forced myself to use one because it was obviously stronger at 75, really happy I dont have to use one anymore other than for procs.
Edit:
If you are playing DRK and guillotine is your best WS, you should be playing a different job
Meh. Playstyles and preferences. Outside of Abyssea I prefer scythe. I haven't done too much in Abyssea outside of xp parties, a few nm's with friends, and a couple zone bosses. I only get to play at odd times, so the high-end empyrean weapons are a bit out of reach.
I'm not doubting your skills or the numerical advantages of Torcleaver over scythe ws's, it's just the "urdoinitwrong" card has been beat to death, and quite frankly, DRK is a job we can all play however we prefer, because we all know nobody outside of other DRK's give 2 shits about how good GS is over Scythe. If DRK was a more readily accepted endgame job, then the debate for the best possible weapon might matter. But even with Torcleaver and a Caladbolg, you're not impressing anyone other than other DRK's.
That being said, my ws sets need a LOT of work, I'm glad the OP made this thread.